I am not sure what took us so long to get around to it, but the Grand Crew finally got down to business and had a Bordeaux night. Also, I am not sure what took me so long to chronicle the night! I don't know how Godin and Lefsetz do it. Anyway... Sadly Jim was not able to join us for this Grand Crew. His company was missed in addition to his expertise. He out of all of us proabaly has the most experience with Bordeaux wines, especially the classified growths. Oh well, sorry Charlie! We had an incredible night.

Before we get into the wines, let’s discuss. Bordeaux is home to some of the worlds most famous and sought after wines. Prices for said first and second growths can be sky high, but I think there is still value to be found in Bordeaux. If you like wines with those old world, earthy and minerally flavors with a good dose of restrained fruit, then Bordeaux could be your new best friend. Even the non-classified Bordeaux you see for $20 or less can be interesting. That’s where shopping at a wine retailer with whom you can develop a relationship can really pay off. Work with someone you trust, someone who can get to know your palate and make good suggestions.

Ah, enough of that. Now the wines. Vikki started us in delicious fashion with a beautiful Graves Blanc from the Pessac-Léognan AC. This area is famous for its gravel soil and is typically thought to deliver wines superior to that of the rest of Graves to the South. The 03 Chateau Smith Haut Lafite was a beautiful way to start the evening. Golden straw in color with an appley nose, if gave off a small hint of oxidation, but in a very good way. It was full and rich on the palate and reminiscent of salty caramel. A fine pairing with Vikki’s Champagnemarinated shrimp served with Buerre Blanc.

Blooms had a the tough task of finding a cool Bordeaux blanc that WAS NOT from Graves. They scored nicely with the 04 Chateau de Launay. This was brighter and more herbaceous than the Smith Haut Lafite. The acid came through late in the palate as did a touch of creamy oak flavors. Killer wine for sure. Excellent with Blooms adapted monkfish and pineapple dish that he recreated from a childhood memory.
Into the reds we went. Jenn and I thought it’d be fun to rock a little vertical. For Lalande de Pomerol we selected a 95 and 00 Chateau Bertineau st Vincent. We served both with a charcuterie and cheese course, complete with my homemade chicken pate! Jenn loves it when I sauté chicken livers, whip them in the food processor and chill the concoction in Beef Jell-o. I did it all for her. These wines were raging. Both made under the auspices of one Michel Rolland. You can knock this guy or praise him, but the fact remains that he works with some of the finest terroirs in the entire world. So, if you are dealing with fine wine, it is sometimes hard to avoid this guy. Both wines were predominately Merlot of course. The 95 gave off that beautiful, textbook Bordeaux nose. Loads of cedar and cigar box, smoke and stewed fruit. The mid-palate had more in common with cheese and dirt than fruit and I mean that in a good way. Tannins were very soft; the mouthfeel was supple and sublime. The 2000 was much more intense on the nose with aggressive fruit aromas with a more apparent presence of alcohol. Tannins were dusty and integrated well with the abundance of fruit. Both were incredible wines but I would choose the 95 too drink again in the near future.

Have you heard the one about the new members of Grand Crew that made their debut with an 88 Lafite Rothchild? Did you read the card?? Carl and Ruth made an excellent impression and contribution to the evening with the first First Growth to show up at Grand Crew. This wine was ridiculous. On the nose this crazy mentholated and eucalyptus thing opened my sinuses. The velvety structure was nothing short of sexual. The finish was long and took its sweet time unfolding., revealing layers of dark fruit, fennel, bacon and earth. Thank you!
As a backup, in case the Lafite bottle was damaged by several moves over the past 25+ years, Carl and Ruth brought an 04 Chateau Ponet Canet, a 5th growth from Pauillac. This was so different, obviously, than the 88 Lafite. Predominately Cab and Merlot with small amounts of Cab Franc and Petit Verdot, the Ponet Canet drank like a Napa wine. Huge huge huge fruit. Very few Bordeaux characteristics, if any, were apparent.
Where do you go after a bottle from one of the top Chateaus in the world? Thank goodness Victor and

Krassi were up next… they never disappoint and were definitively up to the challenge. Second Growth, anyone? Nice! 97 Chateau Leoville-Las Cases should do the trick. This Saint Julien chateau holds vineyards just across a tributary from Latour. Nice neighbor to have. I wonder if there is a vintners version of penis envy… are they always secretly checking each other out? Anyway.. the 97 was beautiful. Perfect red and blue fruit on the nose with cedar notes. Strong and powerful palate followed by a long seductive finish. Krassi wowed us with a Rabbit Terrine au aspic served with celery root, apple and mustard dressing. Trés délicieux.


Robert Parker loved the 98 vintage in Pomerol. In fact, he rated the Right bank ACs far higher than the usual superstars of the Left. Perhaps he was thinking of Jill and Dan’s 98 Chateau Nenin, a property which is now managed by Chateau Leoville Las Cases. This was true elegance. The nose was beautiful and feminine, showing mystery and complexity. Aromas of perfume were followed by balanced flavors of red and blue fruit. Tannins were soft and very well integrated. Gorgeous soft Merlot that was excellent along side Jill’s Beef Bourgogne. Dan must have a secret connection for mushrooms…

Dessert time! I am reading the Billionaire’s Vinegar. Every page it is Lafite this, Y’Quem that. No one besides Billionaires get to drink this stuff on a regular basis, but here was the grand crew rocking out both of these on one night. Check out that book by the way… it is a great read, a real page-turner. It reads like a true crime novel, which I guess it is.
Peter and Jane, how do I love thee? Let me count the ways. From the couple that blew my mind at the inaugural Grand Crew 12 months before with the insane dessert “Pavlova,” tonight came the oldest bottle of wine I had ever handled. 1978 Chateau d’Yquem. They gave me the honor of opening it. The bottle showed good fill level just above the shoulders. I applied the slightest pressure to the cork with the horn of the wine key and the cork immediately plunged into the wine. We poured everything out into our glasses right away as to avoid prolonged cork contact. It was rich and amber in color, like Samuel Adams beer. The nose was pickly and smelled slightly of oxidation. The sweetness took a back seat on the palate to nutty and salty flavors. It was almost like a lighter Madeira or a white port, but with a pronounced salinity. I feel that maybe the cork on this wine lost its seal somewhere along the way, permitting too much oxygen contact. Regardless, this was a pleasure and an honor to drink. I was three years old when these grapes succumbed to botrytis.

I love Bordeaux. There is nothing like it. Napa has abandoned its roots and no longer seeks to deliver nuance and complexity like Warren Winiarski did 40 years ago. Now it is all about power and strength. Bordeaux, as we saw from Michel Rolland’s wine, has taken a few pages from Napa’s book, but still delivers subtlety. Still delivers multi-dimensional experiences for the wine drinker.
Next stop 2009 and the Grand Crew heads down under for a quick tour of Aussie and NZ. See you there ya banana bender.